Description
1). What made modern America modern?
To answer this question, decide what was the most important
development/person/event, etc., for EACH of those five categories for the period 1865-1920 and explain why it was the most important in helping to make “modern America modern.”
Heat, Pleasure, Communication, Motion,Heat
Identifying the most important development, etc., is a beginning step, but the most important part of the essay comes in how well you defend your choices. Picking out five developments, people, etc. is not hard, establishing the evidence and creating a convincing argument about why those five things mattered most is the key to the question.
1. Heat
∙ Momentum
2. Motion
∙ Railroads, cars, etc
o Carnegie (steel)
o Vanderbilt (railroads)
o Rockefeller (oil)
3. Communication’
∙ Invention of the telephone
∙ Industrial Revolution (choose inventions)
4. Pleasure
∙ Consumerism
∙ Buy products to increase pleasure
5. Fear
∙ Influenced by fear
∙ Immigration instilled fear, losing jobs, culture, etc
∙ 1924 Immigration Act
∙ Jim Crow based on fear
o African Americans are going to take over government and their jobs
2). Two of the central questions for this course are “What is America?” and “What is an American?” In class, we have examined multiple ways that the idea of “America” and the idea of an “American” evolved in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. A crucial concept that became a standard assumption for many Americans was that the U.S. was a “melting pot,” and the process of “melting” immigrants into a national mold made the U.S. the remarkably strong nation that it became in the 20th Century. Using material covered in lectures, discussions, readings, and other assignments, answer the following question:
We also discuss several other topics like maher henary
Is the concept of America as a “melting pot” a valid one to use for immigration and the reaction to it in the late 19th and early 20th centuries?
▪ Define the concept of “melting pot” and its origins. ▪ Melting Pot came from a stage play written by Isreael Zangwill in 1908 ▪ Story of David Quizano (fictional Russian Jewish immigrant) who is intent on moving to US after family dies in violent anti Semitic riot in Russia
▪ Melting pot metaphor for races, cultures or individuals
1
▪ Explain how the immigration of the late 19th-early 20th centuries challenged existing notions of an “American” and how those immigrants helped to change the U.S. economy, American culture, and the look, feel, and livability of U.S. cities.
▪ Each immigrant had varied cultural backgrounds and was essential in molding America’s public identity.
▪ Known as shelter
▪ Americans wanted to strip them of their culture and Americanize the immigrants
▪ Immigrants gave the US an economic edge in the world economy, bring in new ideas and entrepeanual spirt, increase trade and invest profitably in the global economy, fill jobs most Americans don’t want
▪ Explain the emergent hostility to the “new” immigration and the rise of laws restricting immigration. If you want to learn more check out biology 114 exam 1
We also discuss several other topics like apph 1040 gatech
▪ States started to become hostile to immigrants because they believed they were stealing their jobs and taking away from their American culture ▪ Seen as cultural and economic threats If you want to learn more check out ametabolous
▪ Prior to 1800s little to no federal government control of flow of immigrants
▪ 1819 immigrants were required to report their arrival (weak) ▪ Page Act of 1875 targeted Asian laborers, convicts and prostitutes by denying them entry to US
▪ Chinese Exclusion Act 1882 banned Chinese immigrants ▪ The rise of the melting pot Julia Higgins
▪ 1917 required literacy test
▪ 1907 Japanese voluntarily limited immigrants Gentlemen Act ▪ 1924 stricter immigrant act excluded Japanese
▪
Provide an answer to whether “melting pot” is a valid concept to apply to that time period.
I believe it was a valid concept due to the metaphorical meaning, however I do not believe the positive connotation should be associated with the term. I believe that most Americans were not thrilled with the idea and did try to make the immigrants
feel unwanted or that they must give up their own culture. Forced immigrants to ostracize the next wave of immigrants. I believe that it symbolized the end of cultural acceptance. Americans wanted to believe they would be happily to let immigrants in.
3). Two of the central questions for this course are “What is America?” and “What is an American?” In class, we have examined multiple ways that the idea of “America” and an “American” evolved in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. One of the key places and inspirations for the development of “American” identity is the West. Using material covered in lectures, discussions, readings, and other assignments, answer the following question:
• What is more important, what we want to believe about the West or what the West was?
To answer this questions students need to: We also discuss several other topics like soci 282 study guide
• Explain the popular vision of the West (at least partially as represented in popular culture—how the West was used in films, advertisements, political personas, and other forms).
• Popular vision of West: Cowboys, badass, Marlboro man
• Good and bad were distinguishable
• Hollywood created image that the cowboys were good and the Indians were bad • Helps people find their identity
• Marlboro advertisements used men to show mostly as cowboys in West, military tattoo on back of hand,
• Indians were savage
• Frontier over meant you couldn’t go get land in West
• Compare that vision to the more realistic history of the West and westward expansion. Don't forget about the age old question of carol erbes
• The "White man" is usually either seen as the brutal force defeating Indians or as the democratic adventurer exploring our land. It is not that easy
• Many different tribes not only known as Indians
• American settlers came in conflict with Indians, Indian Removal Act which resulted in the infamous Trail of Tears, relocated from west of Mississippi to what is now Oklahoma
• Consequences of western development: economic expansion, environmental (bison, habitat destruction and pollution)
• Wounded knee occurred
• Showed symbol of the inhumanity of the U.S. government policy toward Native Americans
• Government demanded size of weapons, shots fired accidently and marked the last showdown of Native Americans and US Army.
• Nat Love Deadwood Dick BLACK COWBOY
Argue which one of the two is more important in understanding the West and understanding American identity. Or perhaps, explain how the two notions are inseparable.
• I believe that the actual representation of the West is more important.
It is sad to say that some people do not know that the Hollywood made
image of the West is nothing but a myth. It is inevitable to say that the
media has distorted many things in the past
4) Who won the long peace that followed the
surrender at Appomattox in 1865, particularly if
one considers the period from 1865-1877?
• Students are free to define the “who” of their answer. Some possibilities include: Republican leaders, big business, African Americans (including former slaves), southern white
supremacists, or even immigrants.
• Answers to this question should:
• Establish a basic chronology of Reconstruction that explains why Radical Reconstruction developed, what key legislation and Constitutional amendments shaped Reconstruction and the meaning of freedom, and what key moments and ideas that brought an end to Reconstruction.
• Huge win because it came from them having nothing
to having some rights
• Radical reconstruction developed due to the poor
revisions of President Johnson during the Presidential
Reconstruction
What was passed during this time?
• Civil Rights Act of 1866 Confers citizenship on African Americans and
guarantees equal rights.
• Reconstruction Acts Congress divides the former Confederacy into
five military districts and requires elections in which African American
men can vote.
• Fourteenth Amendment Ratified guarantees due process and equal
protection under the law to African Americans.
• Fifteenth Amendment Ratified extends the vote to all male citizens
regardless of racer or previous condition of servitude.
• FortySecond Congress
• Five black members in the House of Representatives: Benjamin S.
Turner of Alabama; Josiah T. Walls of Florida; and Robert Brown
Elliot, Joseph H. Rainey and Robert Carlos DeLarge of South
Carolina.
• First African American Governor
• P. B. S. Pinchback, acting governor of Louisiana from December 9,
1872 to January 13, 1873.
• Democrats Control the Fortythird Congress
• For the first time since before the Civil War, Democrats control both
houses of Congress. Robert Smalls, black hero of the Civil War,
elected to Congress as representative of South Carolina. Blanche K.
Bruce elected to U. S. Senate.
• Civil Rights Act of 1875 enacted by Congress
• This act guaranteed equal rights to African Americans in public
accommodations and jury service. Ruled unconstitutional in 1883.
• Reconstruction Ends
• Sophisticated answers will explore the ways that the memory of Reconstruction has changed over time in scholarship and in popular culture, the ways that this answer has changed over time.
• Reconstruction was seen as a failure
1 Challenges: white resistance, carpetbaggers
motivated by greed and corruption, Ku Klux Klan which
eventually led to Jim Crow Laws and blacks were once
again treated poorly
• Added 13,14 and 15th amendment, freedom bureau
and bill of rights, new industry, new churchs and
schools
• All answers should offer an argument about the long-term legacies of Reconstruction and its aftermath.
∙ Birth of Nation
o Black people take over the legislature during
reconstruction
4) Who won the long peace that followed the
surrender at Appomattox in 1865, particularly if
one considers the period after the 1880s, the rise
of Jim Crow?
• Homer Plessy (looked white) decided to fight against segregation, sat
in railroad car, arrested
• Violated constitutional rights and brought to Supreme court
• Allowed separate but equal
• Jim Crow discriminates African Americans
o Seperated water fountains, schools, etc.
Big Business
• Profited , Captains of Industry or robber barons
• Viewed a heroes and villains
• Brought industrial growth and economic strength to the North
• Control over the market, allowed them to set their own price (laissez
faire)
• Vanderbilt (railroads)
• Used their lack of government interference to their advantage as they
developed their own industries
• Rockefeller (oil)
• Carnegie (steel) made money and said its their obligation to give
money back but direct how to spend it
Revolutionized steel
Carnegie library in every state
• J.P. Morgan (banking house)
•
• Increase demand for labor (satisfied by immigration)
Reconstruction 13th, 14th, 15th amendment
Abolish slavery, gave citizenship, right to vote
Jim Crow took a turn
5) Answers to this question should:
a. Explain the ways that Reconstruction helped build power for African-Americans after emancipation (including legislation and
Constitutional amendments) and establish new meanings of freedom, citizenship, and “American” identity. And then detail how that power declined in the post 1880 period known as Jim Crow and why that decline occurred.
b. Explore the ways that the South fit into the U.S. as a whole, particularly its economic expansion, the white southerner’s need to combat the reality that they lost the Civil War and to control the African American population, and the evolving role of race as a scientific and political category.
c. All answers should offer an argument about ways in which interpretations of the Constitution evolved over time and altered the power of its amendments.
∙ Plessy vs Ferguson argued that it was against constitution for separate
railroad cars
∙ Took it to supreme court, ruled separate but equal setting back civil rights ∙ Lead to Jim Crow
∙ Brown v Board of Education established that separate facilities were
inherently unequal under the law and overturned Plessy
Students may certainly argue that there was no “winner.”
TIMELINE:
Expansion to West 1803
Emancipation Proclamation 1863
Gettysburg Address
Civil War Ends 1865
13th Amendment 1865
Radical Reconstruction
Presidential Reconstruction
Military Reconstruction
14th Amendment 1868
15th Amendment 1870
Plessy v Ferguson 1896
1). What made modern America modern?
To answer this question, decide what was the most important
development/person/event, etc., for EACH of those five categories for the period 1865-1920 and explain why it was the most important in helping to make “modern America modern.”
Heat, Pleasure, Communication, Motion,Heat
Identifying the most important development, etc., is a beginning step, but the most important part of the essay comes in how well you defend your choices. Picking out five developments, people, etc. is not hard, establishing the evidence and creating a convincing argument about why those five things mattered most is the key to the question.
1. Heat
∙ Momentum
2. Motion
∙ Railroads, cars, etc
o Carnegie (steel)
o Vanderbilt (railroads)
o Rockefeller (oil)
3. Communication’
∙ Invention of the telephone
∙ Industrial Revolution (choose inventions)
4. Pleasure
∙ Consumerism
∙ Buy products to increase pleasure
5. Fear
∙ Influenced by fear
∙ Immigration instilled fear, losing jobs, culture, etc
∙ 1924 Immigration Act
∙ Jim Crow based on fear
o African Americans are going to take over government and their jobs
2). Two of the central questions for this course are “What is America?” and “What is an American?” In class, we have examined multiple ways that the idea of “America” and the idea of an “American” evolved in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. A crucial concept that became a standard assumption for many Americans was that the U.S. was a “melting pot,” and the process of “melting” immigrants into a national mold made the U.S. the remarkably strong nation that it became in the 20th Century. Using material covered in lectures, discussions, readings, and other assignments, answer the following question:
Is the concept of America as a “melting pot” a valid one to use for immigration and the reaction to it in the late 19th and early 20th centuries?
▪ Define the concept of “melting pot” and its origins. ▪ Melting Pot came from a stage play written by Isreael Zangwill in 1908 ▪ Story of David Quizano (fictional Russian Jewish immigrant) who is intent on moving to US after family dies in violent anti Semitic riot in Russia
▪ Melting pot metaphor for races, cultures or individuals
1
▪ Explain how the immigration of the late 19th-early 20th centuries challenged existing notions of an “American” and how those immigrants helped to change the U.S. economy, American culture, and the look, feel, and livability of U.S. cities.
▪ Each immigrant had varied cultural backgrounds and was essential in molding America’s public identity.
▪ Known as shelter
▪ Americans wanted to strip them of their culture and Americanize the immigrants
▪ Immigrants gave the US an economic edge in the world economy, bring in new ideas and entrepeanual spirt, increase trade and invest profitably in the global economy, fill jobs most Americans don’t want
▪ Explain the emergent hostility to the “new” immigration and the rise of laws restricting immigration.
▪ States started to become hostile to immigrants because they believed they were stealing their jobs and taking away from their American culture ▪ Seen as cultural and economic threats
▪ Prior to 1800s little to no federal government control of flow of immigrants
▪ 1819 immigrants were required to report their arrival (weak) ▪ Page Act of 1875 targeted Asian laborers, convicts and prostitutes by denying them entry to US
▪ Chinese Exclusion Act 1882 banned Chinese immigrants ▪ The rise of the melting pot Julia Higgins
▪ 1917 required literacy test
▪ 1907 Japanese voluntarily limited immigrants Gentlemen Act ▪ 1924 stricter immigrant act excluded Japanese
▪
Provide an answer to whether “melting pot” is a valid concept to apply to that time period.
I believe it was a valid concept due to the metaphorical meaning, however I do not believe the positive connotation should be associated with the term. I believe that most Americans were not thrilled with the idea and did try to make the immigrants
feel unwanted or that they must give up their own culture. Forced immigrants to ostracize the next wave of immigrants. I believe that it symbolized the end of cultural acceptance. Americans wanted to believe they would be happily to let immigrants in.
3). Two of the central questions for this course are “What is America?” and “What is an American?” In class, we have examined multiple ways that the idea of “America” and an “American” evolved in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. One of the key places and inspirations for the development of “American” identity is the West. Using material covered in lectures, discussions, readings, and other assignments, answer the following question:
• What is more important, what we want to believe about the West or what the West was?
To answer this questions students need to:
• Explain the popular vision of the West (at least partially as represented in popular culture—how the West was used in films, advertisements, political personas, and other forms).
• Popular vision of West: Cowboys, badass, Marlboro man
• Good and bad were distinguishable
• Hollywood created image that the cowboys were good and the Indians were bad • Helps people find their identity
• Marlboro advertisements used men to show mostly as cowboys in West, military tattoo on back of hand,
• Indians were savage
• Frontier over meant you couldn’t go get land in West
• Compare that vision to the more realistic history of the West and westward expansion.
• The "White man" is usually either seen as the brutal force defeating Indians or as the democratic adventurer exploring our land. It is not that easy
• Many different tribes not only known as Indians
• American settlers came in conflict with Indians, Indian Removal Act which resulted in the infamous Trail of Tears, relocated from west of Mississippi to what is now Oklahoma
• Consequences of western development: economic expansion, environmental (bison, habitat destruction and pollution)
• Wounded knee occurred
• Showed symbol of the inhumanity of the U.S. government policy toward Native Americans
• Government demanded size of weapons, shots fired accidently and marked the last showdown of Native Americans and US Army.
• Nat Love Deadwood Dick BLACK COWBOY
Argue which one of the two is more important in understanding the West and understanding American identity. Or perhaps, explain how the two notions are inseparable.
• I believe that the actual representation of the West is more important.
It is sad to say that some people do not know that the Hollywood made
image of the West is nothing but a myth. It is inevitable to say that the
media has distorted many things in the past
4) Who won the long peace that followed the
surrender at Appomattox in 1865, particularly if
one considers the period from 1865-1877?
• Students are free to define the “who” of their answer. Some possibilities include: Republican leaders, big business, African Americans (including former slaves), southern white
supremacists, or even immigrants.
• Answers to this question should:
• Establish a basic chronology of Reconstruction that explains why Radical Reconstruction developed, what key legislation and Constitutional amendments shaped Reconstruction and the meaning of freedom, and what key moments and ideas that brought an end to Reconstruction.
• Huge win because it came from them having nothing
to having some rights
• Radical reconstruction developed due to the poor
revisions of President Johnson during the Presidential
Reconstruction
What was passed during this time?
• Civil Rights Act of 1866 Confers citizenship on African Americans and
guarantees equal rights.
• Reconstruction Acts Congress divides the former Confederacy into
five military districts and requires elections in which African American
men can vote.
• Fourteenth Amendment Ratified guarantees due process and equal
protection under the law to African Americans.
• Fifteenth Amendment Ratified extends the vote to all male citizens
regardless of racer or previous condition of servitude.
• FortySecond Congress
• Five black members in the House of Representatives: Benjamin S.
Turner of Alabama; Josiah T. Walls of Florida; and Robert Brown
Elliot, Joseph H. Rainey and Robert Carlos DeLarge of South
Carolina.
• First African American Governor
• P. B. S. Pinchback, acting governor of Louisiana from December 9,
1872 to January 13, 1873.
• Democrats Control the Fortythird Congress
• For the first time since before the Civil War, Democrats control both
houses of Congress. Robert Smalls, black hero of the Civil War,
elected to Congress as representative of South Carolina. Blanche K.
Bruce elected to U. S. Senate.
• Civil Rights Act of 1875 enacted by Congress
• This act guaranteed equal rights to African Americans in public
accommodations and jury service. Ruled unconstitutional in 1883.
• Reconstruction Ends
• Sophisticated answers will explore the ways that the memory of Reconstruction has changed over time in scholarship and in popular culture, the ways that this answer has changed over time.
• Reconstruction was seen as a failure
1 Challenges: white resistance, carpetbaggers
motivated by greed and corruption, Ku Klux Klan which
eventually led to Jim Crow Laws and blacks were once
again treated poorly
• Added 13,14 and 15th amendment, freedom bureau
and bill of rights, new industry, new churchs and
schools
• All answers should offer an argument about the long-term legacies of Reconstruction and its aftermath.
∙ Birth of Nation
o Black people take over the legislature during
reconstruction
4) Who won the long peace that followed the
surrender at Appomattox in 1865, particularly if
one considers the period after the 1880s, the rise
of Jim Crow?
• Homer Plessy (looked white) decided to fight against segregation, sat
in railroad car, arrested
• Violated constitutional rights and brought to Supreme court
• Allowed separate but equal
• Jim Crow discriminates African Americans
o Seperated water fountains, schools, etc.
Big Business
• Profited , Captains of Industry or robber barons
• Viewed a heroes and villains
• Brought industrial growth and economic strength to the North
• Control over the market, allowed them to set their own price (laissez
faire)
• Vanderbilt (railroads)
• Used their lack of government interference to their advantage as they
developed their own industries
• Rockefeller (oil)
• Carnegie (steel) made money and said its their obligation to give
money back but direct how to spend it
Revolutionized steel
Carnegie library in every state
• J.P. Morgan (banking house)
•
• Increase demand for labor (satisfied by immigration)
Reconstruction 13th, 14th, 15th amendment
Abolish slavery, gave citizenship, right to vote
Jim Crow took a turn
5) Answers to this question should:
a. Explain the ways that Reconstruction helped build power for African-Americans after emancipation (including legislation and
Constitutional amendments) and establish new meanings of freedom, citizenship, and “American” identity. And then detail how that power declined in the post 1880 period known as Jim Crow and why that decline occurred.
b. Explore the ways that the South fit into the U.S. as a whole, particularly its economic expansion, the white southerner’s need to combat the reality that they lost the Civil War and to control the African American population, and the evolving role of race as a scientific and political category.
c. All answers should offer an argument about ways in which interpretations of the Constitution evolved over time and altered the power of its amendments.
∙ Plessy vs Ferguson argued that it was against constitution for separate
railroad cars
∙ Took it to supreme court, ruled separate but equal setting back civil rights ∙ Lead to Jim Crow
∙ Brown v Board of Education established that separate facilities were
inherently unequal under the law and overturned Plessy
Students may certainly argue that there was no “winner.”
TIMELINE:
Expansion to West 1803
Emancipation Proclamation 1863
Gettysburg Address
Civil War Ends 1865
13th Amendment 1865
Radical Reconstruction
Presidential Reconstruction
Military Reconstruction
14th Amendment 1868
15th Amendment 1870
Plessy v Ferguson 1896