Limited time offer 20% OFF StudySoup Subscription details

ECU - PHIL 2271 - Class Notes - Week 4

Created by: Rachel Notetaker Elite Notetaker

> > > > ECU - PHIL 2271 - Class Notes - Week 4

ECU - PHIL 2271 - Class Notes - Week 4

0 5 3 47 Reviews
This preview shows page 1 of a 2 page document. to view the rest of the content
background image Philosophy of Art – W4 9/18-9/20 [***Classes on September 11, 13, & 18 were canceled due to 
Hurricane Florence***]
Tolstoy’s Critique: art is about beauty Beauty – objective & subjective o Objective beauty doesn’t exist Aesthetic value o Art produces aesthetic emotion Conclusion Tolstoy wants to prove is:  o Therefore, the objective definition is nothing but the subjective  conception differently expressed Only explicitly states one reason *Discipline specific Ex: geography course *Rules of reasoning applies to all (biology, religion, etc.) Is something art if it provokes a feeling of emotion (pleasure)
Premise 1: 
We acknowledge something to be objectively beautiful (absolutely 
perfect) only because we receive from the manifestation of this 
absolute perfection a certain kind of pleasure
o argument in form of P therefore, Q is not a valid argument form  premise could be true while the conclusion could be false 
and vice versa
Tolstoy’s assuming if the premise is true the conclusion is 
Is the argument valid? Is it sound? (must have form and all premises must 
be true)
Tolstoy’s hidden argument: If we acknowledge something to be objectively beautiful only because 
we receive from the manifestation of this absolute perfection a certain 
kind of pleasure, then the objective definition is nothing but the 
subjective conception differently expressed 
o Therefore, objective definition (beauty) is the subjective  conception different expressed Making assumptions the premise is obvious is not a valid 
Philosophy of art requires scientific theories to be correct If scientific claim is false, then the philosophical theory is incorrect o Only requires one case that claims otherwise to prove it false (ex: Tolstoy’s theory)

This is the end of the preview. Please to view the rest of the content
Join more than 18,000+ college students at East Carolina University who use StudySoup to get ahead
School: East Carolina University
Department: Philosophy
Course: Intro to Philosophy of Art
Professor: Dr. George Bailey
Term: Fall 2018
Tags: Tolstoy, Art, and what is art
Name: PHIL 2271: Intro to Philosophy of Art
Description: Talked about Tolstoy's theory on defining art
Uploaded: 09/28/2018
2 Pages 41 Views 32 Unlocks
  • Better Grades Guarantee
  • 24/7 Homework help
  • Notes, Study Guides, Flashcards + More!
Join StudySoup for FREE
Get Full Access to ECU - Class Notes - Week 4
Join with Email
Already have an account? Login here
Log in to StudySoup
Get Full Access to ECU - Class Notes - Week 4

Forgot password? Reset password here

Reset your password

I don't want to reset my password

Need help? Contact support

Need an Account? Is not associated with an account
Sign up
We're here to help

Having trouble accessing your account? Let us help you, contact support at +1(510) 944-1054 or

Got it, thanks!
Password Reset Request Sent An email has been sent to the email address associated to your account. Follow the link in the email to reset your password. If you're having trouble finding our email please check your spam folder
Got it, thanks!
Already have an Account? Is already in use
Log in
Incorrect Password The password used to log in with this account is incorrect
Try Again

Forgot password? Reset it here