The following arguments were abstracted from newspaper articles, editorials, and letters to the editor. Use the method presented in this section to construct argument patterns. If a statement is redundant or plays no role in the argument, do not include it in the pattern. 1 The conditions under which many food animals are raised are unhealthy for humans. 2 To keep these animals alive, large quantities of drugs must be administered. 3 These drugs remain in the animals’ flesh and are passed on to the humans who eat it.
Read moreTable of Contents
1.1
Arguments, Premises, and Conclusions
1.2
Recognizing Arguments
1.3
Deduction and Induction
1.4
Validity, Truth, Soundness, Strength, Cogency
1.5
Argument Forms: Proving Invalidity
1.6
Extended Arguments
2.1
Varieties of Meaning
2.2
The Intension and Extension of Terms
2.3
Definitions and Their Purposes
2.4
Definitional Techniques
2.5
Criteria for Lexical Definitions
3.1
Fallacies in General
3.2
Fallacies of Relevance
3.3
Fallacies of Weak Induction
3.4
Fallacies of Presumption, Ambiguity, and Illicit Transference
3.5
Fallacies in Ordinary Language
4.1
The Components of Categorical Propositions
4.2
Quality, Quantity, and Distribution
4.3
Venn Diagrams and the Modern Square of Opposition
4.4
Conversion, Obversion, and Contraposition
4.5
The Traditional Square of Opposition
4.6
Venn Diagrams and the Traditional Standpoint
4.7
Translating Ordinary Language Statements into Categorical Form
5.1
Standard Form, Mood, and Figure
5.2
Venn Diagrams
5.3
Rules and Fallacies
5.4
Reducing the Number of Terms
5.5
Ordinary Language Arguments
5.6
Enthymemes
5.7
Sorites
6.1
Symbols and Translation
6.2
Truth Functions
6.3
Truth Tables for Propositions
6.4
Truth Tables for Arguments
6.5
Indirect Truth Tables
6.6
Argument Forms and Fallacies
7.1
Rules of Implication I
7.2
Rules of Implication II
7.3
Rules of Replacement I
7.4
Rules of Replacement II
7.5
Conditional Proof
7.6
Indirect Proof
7.7
Proving Logical Truths
8.1
Symbols and Translation
8.2
Using the Rules of Inference
8.3
Quantifier Negation Rule
8.4
Conditional and Indirect Proof
8.5
Proving Invalidity
8.6
Relational Predicates and Overlapping Quantifiers
8.7
Identity
9
Analogy and Legal and Moral Reasoning
10
Causality and Mills Methods
11
Probability
12
Statistical Reasoning
13
Hypothetical/Scientific Reasoning
14
Science and Superstition
Textbook Solutions for A Concise Introduction to Logic
Chapter 1.6 Problem 2
Question
1 The development of carbon-embedded plastics, otherwise called “composits,” is an important new technology because
2 it holds the key for new aircraft and spacecraft designs. This is so because
3 these composits are not only stronger than steel but lighter than aluminum.
( Thomas H. Maugh II, “Composits—The Lightweight Champs of Aircraft Industry”)
Solution
Step 1 of 3
An argument consists of one or more premises and a conclusion. A statement that is used to derive the conclusion of an argument is the premise of that argument. There can be one or more premises in an argument that can be used to derive the conclusion which is unique for a given argument.
Step 2 of 3
The given argument is:
1. The development of carbon-embedded plastics, o
Subscribe to view the
full solution
full solution
Title
A Concise Introduction to Logic 12
Author
Patrick J. Hurley
ISBN
9781285196541